TUTORIAL FROM ENERGY
PSYCHOLOGY INTERACTIVE |
NOTE:
This tutorial is being revised into a chapter for a forthcoming book on energy psychology,
The Promise of Energy Psychology: Revolutionary Tools for Dramatic Personal Change,
by David Feinstein, Donna Eden, and Gary Craig, to be published by Tarcher/Penguin.
It was written by Feinstein in close consultation with Craig and Eden and will be targeted
for a sophisticated lay audience. Many of the clinical examples are drawn, with
permission, from Gary Craig's EFT website, www.emofree.com.
About footnotes: Click on the "footnote" number in the body of the text to go to
the corresponding footnote.
Click on the footnote's number to return to the text. PRINTABLE VERSION PDF Format |
|
|
Chapter 3 |
|
|
|
Many psychological
problems can be treated without the need to pass through laborious stages of discovery,
emoting, and cognitive restructuring which are frequently considered to be the hallmarks
of true psychotherapy. |
|
Fred Gallo, Ph.D.
Energy Psychology |
|
|
|
| If you enter the name of almost any
psychological or psychiatric problem you can think of into the search engine of the EFT
website (www.emofree.com), you are likely to find that someone has
worked with it using energy methods and has reported some success. This does not mean that
a few thumps on a set of acupuncture points is going to cure schizophrenia,1 but
it does mean that people have found ways to use energy methods to provide some genuine
assistance to individuals with psychotic disorders such as schizophrenia, along with an
enormous range of other conditions.
How do tapping, rubbing, doing
the Nine Gamut Procedure, and saying the Setup Affirmation and Reminder Phrase combine so
that an unwanted emotional or behavioral response stops occurring?
As you saw in Chapter 1, a
harmless sight, sound, smell, feeling, or thought (the trigger) leads to a sequence of
chemical events in your brain that result in the unwanted emotion or behavior.
As you saw in Chapter 2,
activating in your mind the image or situation that triggers the whole sequence while
simultaneously doing the tapping seems to send electrical impulses that block the unwanted
response.
In many cases, this immediately
resolves the problem for which the person is seeking help. In other cases, a web of
interrelated triggers must be identified and neutralized one by one. That is the detective
work we will introduce in this chapter. |
|
|
The Problems that Respond the Most Quickly |
|
|
The methods of energy psychology can be applied at numerous
levels. The core strategy is to extinguish a dysfunctional conditioned response. A
conditioned response is a feeling or behavior that is programmed to immediately occur when
a particular type of stimulus appears (an internal image or external situation).
You get on an airplane, and you feel panic. You hear the name of your girlfriends
old lover and jealous rage envelops you. You say "no" when a friend asks you to
serve on a committee that holds no interest for you, and guilt plagues you for hours. A TV
ad reminds you of your mother, who died in 1992, and you are, for the thousandth time,
sent into inconsolable grief. Your spouses voice gets a bit loud when making a
request and you want to come out swinging.
When there is a clear relationship
between an internal or external stimulus and an unwelcome emotion or an automatic
behavior, a fairly routine application of the EFT Basic Recipe will usually interrupt the
pattern. To review, you specify the response you wish to change and give a 0 to 10 rating
for the level of distress you feel when you bring it to mind. You formulate the Setup
Affirmation and state it out loud while massaging points on your chest that are tender.
You do the Sandwich: a) the acupoint Tapping Sequence, while stating your Reminder Phrase
at each point, b) the Nine Gamut Procedure, and c) the Tapping Sequence again. You do
another assessment and repeat the Sandwich with slight modifications to the Setup
Affirmation and the Reminder Phrase. You continue until the distress you feel while
mentally holding the image or memory has been eliminated.
Over the next few days, try this with
several clear cut issues, where your response to a situation you sometimes encounter is
very specific, such as:
"When I start to become tired, I
automatically turn on the television" ("Even though I have this
weakness for television . . .").
"My clothes wind up on the
floor, even though I intend to hang them when I take them off" ("Even though
I have this habit of leaving my clothes on the floor . . .").
"Every time I sit down to do the
taxes, I become anxious" ("Even though I feel anxiety whenever I start
to do my taxes . . .").
"When I see my daughter having
fun, I begin to dwell on her poor grades" ("Even though I have this
preoccupation with my daughters grades . . .").
Follow the Basic Recipe exactly as it
is described in Chapter 2 and you may be surprised by how frequently it is effective in
changing your responses. The approach puts into your hands (literally) skills that can
free you of emotions that limit you and that make life less enjoyable. Once you have
mastered the basic methods taught in the previous chapter, you will be able to change your
internal programming in relationship to a wide range of issues. One of the comments we
hear the most frequently from those we train is some version of, "I wish I would have
known this years ago."
The following are actual examples that
illustrate the range of issues where simply applying the Basic Recipe gave someone relief:
performance fears for a 19-year-old gymnast, flashbacks and insomnia a woman was
experiencing following two automobile accidents during a six-week period, a refinery
worker stopping smoking after 35 years, a womans extreme anxiety prior to bladder
surgery, a six-year-old girls psychosomatic pains, a mothers fear of flying
that was being communicated to her one-year-old daughter, depression suffered by a single
mom with two teenage daughters, a womans intense lifelong craving for chocolate and
ice cream, a 13-year-old boys fear of the dark, a boy with an intense allergic
reaction to horses, another boy with severe dyslexia, a womans pain after
reconstructive surgery for a damaged knee. You can read details about each of these, as
well as hundreds of others, at www.emofree.com.
Of course a routine application of the
methods will not be effective in every situation. Even in cases where a triggering
stimulus and unwanted response can be readily identified, other factors may be involved
and need attention. Four considerations for increasing the effectiveness of the tapping
protocol were described at the end of Chapter 2aspects of the problem, psychological
reversals, scrambled energies, and energy toxins.
In addition, given the complexities of
human emotional life, psychological problems do not necessarily break down into a clearly
identifiable stimulus-and-response pattern. Careful observation that helps you identify
where to focus your attention is often required. Is the progress being blocked by hidden
aspects or psychological reversals? Is special understanding required for working with a
particular type of problem, such as depression or an addiction? Addressing such questions
is the topic of this chapter. It teaches by example, describing how energy psychology has
been successfully used with a range of individuals and conditions. It also gives you some
insight into the dynamics of each condition. Even if you do not suffer with a specific
problem discussed below, some of the principles for overcoming that problem may apply to
situations you do encounter, so we encourage you to read each section. The descriptions
are written to teach basic strategies and highlight possibilities as much as to address
the particular problem. |
|
|
Fears
and Phobias |
|
|
Energy
psychology treatments with fears and phobias are quite familiar, in part because the
outcomes are so easy to demonstrate, as when the woman in South Africa triumphantly walked
up to and touched the snake that had terrorized her a few minutes earlier. But fears and
phobias are by no means the only emotional difficulties that respond to this approach.
Energy interventions with traumatic memories, anxiety, depression, addictions,
self-defeating habits, and physical conditions will be presented later in the chapter. For
each topic, case examples will be followed by a discussion of the principles involved in
working with that issue.
Fear of Public Speaking
Sue had a speech
impediment that resulted in an intense fear of public speaking. She attended a workshop
presented by Gary and his associate Adrienne Fowlie. During the lunch break, Sue asked
them for help with her fear. She showed them a scar on her neck where an operation for
throat cancer had been performed. As a result of the operation, she could not speak
normally and it was difficult to understand her. Not surprisingly, she was not fond of
public speaking. In fact, she was terrified of it, with a range of the physiological
symptoms of phobia, from a racing heart to feelings of nausea. To make matters worse, she
was a sergeant in the Army and frequently had to "public speak" in front of her
troops.
Two rounds of the Basic Recipe were
applied, and she overcame the fear in a few minutes, at least to the extent that she no
longer felt fear when thinking about speaking in front of a group. When the
workshop reconvened, Gary asked her to come up on stage to further test the results. As
she walked toward the stage, she reported that some fear was upon her again, but it was
"only a 3," down from the "usual 10." Another round of the Basic
Recipe was applied on the stage as she faced the audience, and her fear rating fell to
"0." She then grabbed the microphone and enchanted the 100 people in the
audience as she told the story of what happened during the lunch break. She was calm and
poised. Her speech impediment was still there, of course, but her fear and the
accompanying physical reactions were gone. While eliminating the fear of public speaking
doesnt necessarily make someone a great speaker, it does remove the rapid pounding
of the heart, the dry mouth, and other symptoms so that one is then comfortable and able
to cultivate public speaking skills.
Claustrophobia
A 37-year-old woman who had a
debilitating stroke at age 30 volunteered herself for treatment in a class David was
teaching. Shortly after her stroke, she had been placed into an MRI machine and became
fearful and confused. She panicked, could not get out, and terror took over. She had been
claustrophobic ever since, to the point that she could not sleep with the lights out or
even under a blanket, could not drive through a tunnel, or get into an elevator. Besides
being enormously inconvenient, this was confidence-shattering as she worked to get her
speech back.
Within 20 minutes of reprogramming her energy response to enclosed
places using the tapping sequence, her anxiety when thinking about being in an enclosed
space went from "10+" on the 10-point scale down to 0. To test this, David
suggested that during the break, she and her partner return to their room and that she get
into the closet. After she entered the closet and closed the door, her partner turned out
the lights. She stayed there five minutes with no anxiety. When she returned to report
what happened to the group, she said the only problem was that she found it
"boring." The rest of the group, which 50 minutes earlier had witnessed her
report that her distress was 10+ when even thinking about an enclosed space, was amazed.
That evening she slept with the lights out and under the covers for the first time in
seven years. Her partner was elated.
Six weeks after this single session, the following e-mail arrived:
"You are not going to believe this! The test of all claustrophobia tests happened to
me. I got stuck in an elevator by myself for nearly an hour. In the past I would have gone
nuts and clawed the door off, but I was calm and sat down on the floor and waited
patiently for the repair men to arrive. . . . It was an amazing confirmation that I
am no longer claustrophobic!!!!!!!! Thank you. Thank you." Based upon a growing body
of clinical evidence, her phobia is not likely to return unless bad fortune retraumatizes
her in a situation that involves an enclosed space.
The Nature of Phobias
You can imagine
the years of self-recrimination both women suffered prior to the treatments. We live in a
culture that views irrational fear as a character flaw and that encourages people to act
tough. Both women actually displayed tremendous courage in coping with their fears, but
the internal wiring was such that the harder they tried to push through, the stronger the
fears became. With treatment that addressed the wiring rather than the feelings or the
behavior, the fears dissolved in minutes.
About 10% of
the population suffers from one or more phobias. Phobias cause untold misery and often
severely limit the lives of those who have them. There are hundreds of possible phobias,
but the Basic Recipe can be effective regardless of what triggers the irrational fear.
Because it involves the same neurological process, you use the same strategy whatever the
trigger. Among the most common triggers are fears of: |
|
| Public speaking |
Heights |
Snakes |
Enclosed places |
| Spiders and other
insects |
Dentists |
Needles |
Driving |
| Open spaces |
Flying |
Bridges |
Rejection |
| Bodies of water |
Speed |
Telephones |
Men |
| Disease |
Dogs |
Bees |
Being alone |
|
|
There is a world of difference between a normal fear and a phobia.
Fear is a survival mechanism, an evolutionary achievement that helps us avoid danger. It
bypasses the rational mind and sets into motion a sequence of automated responses that
helped our ancestors survive in the face of mortal danger. If you are driving your car and
a truck pulls out of a driveway in front of you, you dont want lots of inner
dialogue before your foot hits the brake. Some of our fear-based behaviors are needed to
bypass the more well-considered but so much slower rational mind. An automatic fear
response becomes attached or "conditioned" to a situation based on a combination
of inherited reactions (e.g., the "fight-or-flight" response) and experiences
that teach you about what is dangerous.
A phobia or irrational fear is a fear that
has become attached to an object or a situation that, objectively, does not actually pose
a danger or threat, or to a situation where the threat is better managed by normal caution
than by a full-blown emergency response. Caution when you see a snake or a spider is
adaptive. Either may be dangerous and able to cause you harm. But to experience a pounding
heart, headache, nausea, vomiting, sweat, tears, or any of a long list of other symptoms
of excessive fear is not only useless, it makes you less effective in the situation. The
phobic response, the level of fear that exceeds normal caution, contributes nothing to
your safety.
People are often amazed by how quickly a
lifelong phobia may vanish. This, of course, does not cause them to step into harms
way. The process doesn't make them stupid. They don't suddenly jump off tall buildings or
kiss grizzly bears. Normal caution and concern are not erased by rebalancing the meridian
energies in order to neutralize a phobic response. However, people who have eliminated a
phobia using energy techniques tend to have less fear in the situation about which they
were originally phobic than other people. Almost everyone, for example, has some fear
response to heights. Ask 100 people to look down from the top of a tall building, though
they are in total safety, and many of them will feel at least a bit queasy, a
physiological component of the fear response. By contrast, those who have completely
eliminated a height phobia using the tapping sequence don't even feel queasy. The wiring
has been changed. They are left only with a healthy caution.
Applying the Basic Recipe to a Phobia
It is usually
quite simple to establish the Setup Affirmation and Reminder Phrase for a phobia. For
instance: "Even though I have this fear of heights . . ." (Setup Affirmation)
and "Fear of heights" (Reminder Phrase). It doesn't matter how intense the
phobia is or how long you have had it. This surprises many people because they tend to
think that longstanding, intense phobias are "deeply ingrained" and must take
months or years to eliminate. Not so with an energy approach. While some phobias do take
longer to resolve than others, this is not because of their intensity or longevity.
Rather, it is because of their complexity. The fear of heights may be a simple
conditioned response: situations that involve height trigger panic based on a single
incident, perhaps forgotten long ago. Or it may be more complex, tying into numerous past
episodes: a memory of having once fallen from a tree, an image of having seen someone fall
from a high place, and having had a panic attack while on a ski left. Each is an aspect of
the phobia, and these aspects often need to be treated one at a time to completely
dissolve the phobia.
For many phobias,
it is only necessary to address the most obvious aspect, which is to bring to mind the
object of the fear. Just a few brief trips through the Basic Recipe will usually take care
of it. But if you are not finding relief after several rounds, focus on an early memory
that brings up the fear. Apply the Basic Recipe to it. If another aspect
emergessuppose the memory is of a friend who died when a balcony collapsed and you
are overcome with feelings of grieftreat those feelings. Work with each aspect of
this memory. Remember, your subconscious mind knows what you are processing, and it will
present the elements that require attention. Once you have neutralized this memory, see if
another comes to mind, and treat it. Of course, when you begin, you do not know how many
aspects the problem has. The practical guideline is that you can assume that all the
relevant aspects of the issue have been neutralized when you have no more emotional
intensity about the original fear-producing thought.
Psychological
reversals are less common in phobias than they are in some other conditions, such as
addictions, where they are almost always at play. But if your progress in working with a
fear or phobia becomes blocked, ask yourself what would happen if you no longer had this
fear. On being asked this question, a woman whose fear of flying was not responding to the
tapping blurted out, with some embarrassment, "Then I would have to go on those
dreadful business trips with my husband." Another woman, whose fear traced to a
childhood incident when a man she trusted played a cruel practical joke on her, realized
that if she got over her phobia, she might have to forgive him. The subconscious mind
works in devious ways. Stay alert for inner bargains you may have struck that keep your
fear or phobia engaged for spurious reasons. If you suspect one, formulate a Setup
Affirmation that addresses it (e.g., "Even though I have this resentment of Joe that
I would rather hold onto than overcome my phobia, I deeply love and accept myself").
State the affirmation three times while rubbing sore spots on your chest or tapping the
karate chop points. Then return to the Tapping Sequence.
Once the Phobia is Eliminated, Is the
Result Permanent?
Strange though it
may seem, in our experiences and those of many other practitioners, once a phobia has been
completely eliminated in the office, the gains usually translate beyond the office, and
they usually hold. A fundamental energetic and neurological shift has occurred in
relationship to the triggering situation, and it does not matter if you are simply
thinking about the situation or actually in it. However, if the problem does return,
unless an entirely new experience has re-traumatized the person, it is almost always
because aspects that werent fully addressed in the treatment are becoming involved.
Recall, for instance, the treatment where the spiders movements had not been part of
the initial treatment and had to be addressed in a subsequent round before an actual
spider could be viewed with no fear. Stay alert. As you identify additional aspects of the
problem, use the Basic Recipe with each of them.
Multiple Phobias
Sometimes a
person suffers with several phobias. The guideline is to treat them one at a time. For
example, make sure your snake phobia is totally cleared before you address your
claustrophobia. Then make sure your claustrophobia has been completely neutralized before
you address your driving phobia. In addition, some phobias, called "complex
phobias," are actually several phobias wrapped into one. The fear of flying can be
like that. It might involve 1) the fear of being enclosed in a relatively small area, 2)
the fear of falling, 3) the fear of turbulence, 4) the fear of taking off, 5) the fear of
landing, 6) and the fear of being shut in with people. If you have a complex phobia, treat
each component you are able to identify as if it were a separate problem. This may require
a number of rounds, but persistent use of the Basic Recipe can permanently neutralize even
a complex phobia within a relatively short period of time. |
|
|
Traumatic
Memories and Other Difficult Life-Shaping Events |
|
|
Many people are plagued by traumatic memories. These memories may
have originated from any shock to the system, such as a natural disaster, injury,
accident, or loss. They may also have involved a personal betrayal, such as physical
assault, emotional abuse, rape, or other victimization. Reliving, or even just being
reminded of, a past traumatic incident can be intensely painful. The effects can range
from relatively mild reactions, such as a headache or a stomach ache, to the complete
inability to function. Many people experience a variety of symptoms. Their hearts may
pound when a traumatic memory intrudes. They may find themselves sweating, crying, or
shaking. They may experience sexual dysfunction, grief, anger, depression, or any number
of other emotional or physical problems. And even if the memories dont frequently
come into their consciousness, they may be doing damage behind the scenes, keeping the
person inhibited or defensive and cause self-doubt, suspiciousness, anxiety, or
nightmares.
Energy psychology, as you have seen,
approaches traumatic memories by sending electromagnetic impulses to the brain that
interrupt the intense emotional response the memory has been causing. Unlike many other
therapies, the emphasis is not on analyzing the memory and its meaning. Rather, you work
with the acupoints. You will still, of course, have access to the memory after its
emotional charge has been neutralized, but it will no longer create personal mayhem when
it comes into your mind. And it will no longer be wreaking psychological havoc behind the
scenes.
Some people wonder if treatments that
neutralize the effects of a personal trauma with almost surgical precision rob the person
of the insight and self-knowledge that can be achieved by exploring the problem in depth.
Can you even "get to the bottom" of a psychological issue without examining it
in detail? In our experience, removing the energy disturbance caused by the memory
increases the persons self-understanding. When the emotional overwhelm is
eliminated, peoples attitudes about their memories change almost instantly. They
talk about them differently. Their language shifts from words of fear to those of
understanding. Their demeanor and posture suggest an entirely new, and more composed
relationship to the experience. This is all consistent with the neurological shifts that
have occurred. What has changed is that they can now think and talk about the memory
without being retraumatized. So rather than circumventing self-examination, they now have
more access to their rational facilities to put even the most horrible incident into a
realistic and adaptive perspective. Examples of this can be seen in the following two
stories.
A Childhood Rape That Leads to Subsequent
Sexual Difficulties
Sandy and her
partner came to one of our colleagues2 for pre-marital counseling. Among the issues
they were concerned about was their sexual relationship. Although Sandy had been married
before, she found herself reacting with uncontrollable negative feelings when her fiancé
initiated sexual play. He was willing to be patient, kind, and understanding, and he
seemed genuinely interested that sex be a shared experience. While she freely acknowledged
that she had no problems with his attitude, she still would usually became upset and
turned off by his overtures. They asked for help with this problem, and a private session
with Sandy was arranged.
When she
came in, the therapist gently asked, "Is there something in your earlier years that
you could talk about?" She immediately burst into tears. Red blotches appeared on her
skin, and her words were punctuated with heavy sobbing and gasping as she began to relate
her story: "When I was seven years old, we lived in [a small rural town]. One day my
stepfather took me for a walk down a country road. It was in the summer. We hiked up the
side of a hill. Then we stopped. Then he took off all my clothes. Then he took off all his
clothes."
At this point she was scarcely able to
breathe. The therapist stopped her and said that it was not necessary to go any further.
He had her state her distress rating about the memory, which obviously was a 10. He then
led her through the Tapping Sequence, at first without even doing the Setup. Her intensity
dropped from 10 to 6. At this point, a Setup Affirmation that began "Even though I
still have some of this . . ." was used, followed by another round of tapping. This
time the intensity fell to 2. Then another Setup Affirmation, beginning with, "Even
if I never get completely over this
," and a last round of tapping.
By this time, Sandy was breathing quietly.
Her skin was free of blotches, her eyes were clear, and she was looking at her hands,
lying folded in her lap. The therapist said, "Sandy, as you sit there now, think back
to that hot summer day when your stepfather took you for that walk down that country road.
Think about how you hiked up the side of that hill until you stopped. Think about how he
took off all your clothes. Think of how he took off all his clothes. Now, what do you
get?"
She sat there without moving for maybe
five seconds, then looked up calmly and said, without undue emotion, "Well, I still
hate him." The therapist, after agreeing that hating him might be a reasonable
response and possibly a useful one to keep, then asked, "But what about the distress
you were feeling?"
Again she
paused before answering. This time she laughed as she said, "I don't know. I just
can't get there. Well, that was 20 years ago. I was just a little girl. I couldn't protect
myself then the way I can now. What's the point in getting upset about something like that
. . . I never let that man touch me again, and my kids have never been allowed to be near him. I don't know,
it just doesn't seem to bother me like it did."
After this single session, she no longer
experienced negative feelings in response to her partners sexual advances. On a two
year follow-up, she reported that the problem was "good and gone," and her
partner, now her husband, confirmed that there was no sign of the former difficulties.
Notice, also, that by the end of the session she was speaking of the trauma almost
casually, and she was placing it into a self-affirming framework: "Well, that was 20
years ago. I was just a little girl. I couldn't protect myself then the way I can
now." Such shifts in relationship to a traumatic memory that has been emotionally
cleared using an energy intervention are typical.
Peeling Away the Layers of Sexual Abuse
The above case
is presented because it is so straightforward that it is easy to follow what occurred. One
traumatic incident. One aspect. Instant results. The path is not always so direct. Rachel
told her therapist3 that she had worked
through her childhood sexual abuse history in therapy, but she still felt that fears and
other emotions got in the way of her intimate relationships. Rachel said she "keeps
people at bay" and "loses her center" when she gets involved, and she
explained that this was why her relationships have always "backfired."
The therapist
did not automatically accept her assurance that she had "worked through her childhood
sexual abuse" in her previous therapy. Energy therapists quickly learn that when a
client who has been in conventional treatment makes a statement like that, it doesnt
necessarily mean the emotions have been resolved. The issue may still cause a reaction in
the brain that triggers a dysfunctional emotional response. It is not that they are lying.
"Working through it" often means they have talked about it repeatedly in
therapeutic sessions to gain insight and understanding and to hopefully to feel better
about it. They may have learned to cope with or repress the emotional response, or to
change the subject when the topic comes up. But ask them a pointed question that gets to
the heart of the matter and you will often get cringing, tears, physical upsets, and other
symptoms of a still unresolved issue. Taking a clue from Rachels continuing
difficulty with intimacy, the therapist made a first guess that the emotional aftermath of
her sexual abuse had not been adequately resolved.
She asked
Rachel how she felt talking about her relationships, and Rachel described a physical
reaction. "My stomach feels gurgly and gassy. Its holding onto something, not
letting go. Something is not being processed the way it should be." The therapist
soon had her tapping, using a Setup Affirmation that began, "Although there's
something I can't digest and process . . ." Rachels stomach calmed with the
tapping, and the therapist next asked, "If your digestive system could say what it is
that it can't digest and process, what would that be?" The answer Rachel offered was,
"Too much excitement. I just can't process it. I get overwhelmed." Rachel then
tapped on "Although I get overwhelmed . . ." This led to an insight. "Yes,
part of me hates that feeling . . . but another part of me craves it. It's like teen
energy. I love the excitement."
The therapist
asked her to tune into what it is like to have these two opposing parts, asking if it set
her up for tension or anxiety. Rachel responded that she wanted to learn to contain it
all, to enjoy the excitement without being over-stimulated. She next tapped for
"Although I tend to get over-stimulated . . ." This was followed by Rachel
getting images of herself as a child. She became aware that as a child, if she felt good
about anything, she couldn't contain it. She had to "go out and burn it off."
This had been true in adulthood too. Feeling good made her "want to go out and
party."
The therapist
asked her to again close her eyes, think about feeling good, and notice her response. Did
it give her a calm feeling? Did it give her anxiety? It was as if a light went on in
Rachels head. She realized that this was the core of her inability to have
successful relationships. Whenever she would get close to someone and begin to enjoy the
pleasure, the anxiety would be so strong that she would sabotage the relationship.
So Rachel
tapped for "Although feeling good makes me anxious..." Tears welled up. She
realized that, as a child, at times "the sexual abuse felt good but it was bad."
She was still carrying that strong inner message that it wasn't okay to feel good. She
tapped for "Although I learned that feeling good was bad . . ." and
"Although my child believed that feeling good was bad, I deeply & completely love
and accept my child and I know she was a good girl and it wasn't her fault." This was
all very moving, the first time she had truly felt compassion for how confused that part
of her had been. She next tapped on "releasing this belief that feeling good is
bad."
The 90-minute
session did not end there. Rachel next tapped on the pain of how there was no one to tell
(about the abuse) and no one to help her. She also worked with her grief for all she had
lost by not being able to bond in relationship with others during adulthood. Then, at a
certain point, she got in touch with some very positive childhood memories. She remembered
that she excelled at a certain sport and she felt great about her body when she was really
in the flow, "feeling good and calm at the same time." Her therapist showed her
how to reinforce the feeling of being fully alive yet not over-stimulated by "rubbing
in the positive," using the chest sore spots while recalling this memory and stating
"Just calm and in the flow."
At their next
meeting, Rachel reported: "Connections with people feel different. I feel an easiness
being with people. I just feel closer. It's like the anxiety all went away. There's a part
of me that feels really peaceful now. And I've been really energetic!"
While it is
beyond the scope of any book to suggest that you overcome a history of sexual abuse
without outside help, this case is instructive in several ways. For one thing, it
illustrates how guilt is often a component of unresolved abuse. People tend to focus on
their anger and victimization, but Rachels dilemma that "feeling good is
bad" is not uncommon. Sexual abuse involves our pleasure zones. In some cases, it
felt good as well as horrible or confusing. This is not a popular notion. Social pressure
actually causes people who were abused to focus on their anger and victimization rather
than guilt. Anger and other feelings about having been victimized can be directed
outwardly, toward the abuser, and that is certainly appropriate. But if guilt is there, it
must also be confronted.. Guilt is an "inside job." It requires taking personal
responsibility for an ongoing problem. For this reason, people often resist working on
their own guilt. Those who were abused, however, sometimes need to develop internal
permission to recognize that feelings of guilt are involved if they are to fully resolve
the ongoing emotional problems caused by the abuse.
Applying the Basic Recipe to a Difficult
Memory
Additional
principles illustrated by Rachels case include:
How many
aspects may be involved in a complex issue such as relationship difficulties,
How resolving
one aspect can point to the next one if you simply notice your internal responses,
How current
issues often lead you to earlier memories, and
How rapidly
each aspect may be resolved by using the Basic Recipe. Again, each round requires only
about a minute.
Rachels
case notwithstanding, many traumatic memories can be resolved without treating any aspects
beyond the main memory. A few trips through the Basic Recipe and the energy disturbance
and subsequent emotion no longer occur. The memory will lose its emotional charge, and in
many cases the change is permanent.
Other traumatic
memories, however, have several aspects. They require more time because you need to
identify the aspects and then work with each one. But even if extra rounds of the Basic
Recipe are needed, the time required to defuse a traumatic memory can still be relatively
brief. The most challenging task is identifying the relevant aspects of the memory.
A technique
that can support you in identifying the relevant aspects of a memory or a problem is to
make a mental movie of the memory or the situation on which you are focusing. This helps
the relevant issues become more clear. A traumatic memory is actually already like a short
movie that runs in the theater of your mind. There is a beginning. There are main
characters and events. And there is an end. Usually such "movies" play in a
flash and finish with a familiar unwanted emotion. Because the movie plays so fast, we are
often unaware that it may have different aspects which each contribute to the negative
emotion. The emotional reaction seems to come from the movie as a whole.
If you run the
movie in slow motion, however, the different aspects can be located and then addressed.
And that is exactly the technique we are suggesting. Run the movie in slow motion,
examining it scene by scene. If you are concerned that it might be traumatic to re-imagine
the movie, there is an important in-between step. Begin with the "tearless trauma
technique," where you guess what it would be like to think about the issue,
and use the Basic Recipe to remove some of the charge from the memory until you can
psychologically enter the scene without too much discomfort.
Then, run the
memory as a short mental movie (perhaps one to three minutes). At the same time, narrate
the movie. Describe it out loud. Tell it to a friend or a mirror or a tape recorder
or simply the space in front of you. And, most important, tell it in detail. This
automatically slows the movie because words are much slower than thoughts.
As you tell it
in detail, each aspect will make itself known to you. Stop as soon as you feel any
intensity (remember, this approach is designed to be adapted in ways that
minimize pain) and perform the Basic Recipe on that part of the story as though it were a
separate traumatic memory. Actually, it is a separate traumatic memory. It just got
lost within the larger movie. Continue through the movie, stopping at each aspect. Bring
each to zero, until you can tell the whole story with no negative emotional impact
whatsoever.
Again, many
traumatic memories have only one aspect. Others have two or three. More than three are
relatively rare. Whatever the number, be persistent. If you have several traumatic
memories, use the same strategy you would use for several fears or phobias: treat them one
at a time. Take the most intense memory first and bring it to zero before going on to the
next one. Then the next, until each has been neutralized. In the process, you will likely
feel a sense of freedom and it may actually border on euphoria. It is a tremendous relief
to unload useless baggage. Some people, such as war veterans or victims of ritual abuse
may have hundreds of traumatic memories. As they begin to neutralize some of the memories
working with an energy-oriented practitioner, the generalization effect eventually comes
into play. After they have completely cleared between five and twenty of them, they are
likely to notice that after a point they have little emotional intensity about the
remaining ones. The generalization effect will have neutralized them. So even if your
troubling memories run in the dozens or more, relief need not be far away. |
|
|
ANXIETY |
|
|
The nine percent of Americans who, during any six-month period, are
afflicted with an anxiety disorder share at least one common traitthey hunger for
relief. While fear is an emotion designed to cause us to either flee from danger or to be
fully focused and motivated in situations that demand effective action, if the emergency
response unnecessarily lasts for a prolonged period of time, the experience can be hard to
bear. Fear is a core, visceral survival response designed to cause you to take action.
Anxiety is fear without a specific target or action plan, yet it can readily attach itself
to all manner of perceived threats. It not only fills the mind with panic, dread,
consuming fright, excessive worry, terrifying flashbacks, or seemingly likely horrific
scenarios, it can permeate the body with shakes, nausea, a racing heart, stomach upset,
aching muscles, fatigue, numbness, restlessness, or insomnia. Beyond this psychic and
physical distress, anxiety can interfere with a persons ability to function. In the
circular grip of chronic anxiety, fear of the next episode becomes yet another source of
anxiety. This is not a condition people can ignore. And it also is one they cannot usually
just will themselves out of, though they may wish to do so with all their strength.
A Toddlers Temper Tantrums
Fortunately,
anxiety disorders respond particularly well to energy interventions. You do not need to
identify the target of the anxiety, which is a good thing since anxiety is often
free-floating and doesnt have an identifiable target, or it is triggered by pop-up
targets, readily jumping from one perceived threat to another. The following scenario,
while not about anxiety per se, illustrates how the methods can be effective even when you
dont exactly know the source of the problem.
A three-year-old boy, Evan, had uncontrollable temper tantrums
whenever he could not have his way. Evans parents were both busy physicians, and he
was often cared for by other people. Gina and her husband, a couple who frequently had
this job, brought Evan as they visited a friend with the intention that they all take a
walk in the woods. Evan was very shy when they arrived at the friends home, turning
away from her greeting, but he opened up as they walked along the trail, and he was in
great spirits by the end of the hike. They all then sat alongside a creek near the
friends home, tossing rocks into the water.
When it was time to go, Evan didnt want to leave and he went
into a violent temper tantrum. Gina carried him up the hill as he screamed and sobbed,
struggling in her arms. She put him in his car seat and left the door open. He continued
screaming as the adults moved away from the car to talk.
The friend, Blair, asked what they usually do when he gets like
this. "We can't do anything," Gina said. "He just has to have his way. If I
talk to him it gets worse and we end up fighting, so I have to leave him alone." She
went on to explain that Evan was seeing a psychotherapist and a speech therapist. Blair
asked what the professionals suggest be done during this kind of episode. "Nothing.
They just let him cry himself out."
Blair, 4 while not a professional therapist, had some training in EFT. He
asked Ginas permission to "try something," and Gina had no objection. He
walked over to the still screaming child and said, "It's okay. I know it's hard for
you right now." He reached down, took Evans little hand, and started tapping on
his karate chop point as he said, "Even though you're really upset right now, we all
love you." He tapped around Evans eyes. "Even though you're really upset
right now, you're okay just the way you are." He tapped on the boys face, then
his chest, and the crying stopped. Evan began smiling, and wiped his tears away. Blair
finished the round, tapping the back of Evans hand, held it for a moment, then let
go. Evan sat quietly. Gina was dumbstruck. "What did you do? He can't listen to
anything when he gets like that, and touching him makes him really mad! What did you
do?"
This story (and many others like it) suggests that the Basic Recipe
works whether or not you believe it will and whether or not you understand the cause of
the feelings. The tapping sent signals to Evans brain that interrupted the tantrum,
and his angry feelings ceased. Because he was already in the midst of the emotion, no
Reminder Phrase was necessary.
An Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder
Diane was, in her late teens,
diagnosed with Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD), an anxiety condition that may involve
ritualized behaviors, repetitive thoughts about questions such as "Did I lock the
front door," and difficulty in adjusting to new situations. Now 30 and wanting to
become pregnant, she wished to go off the medication she had been taking for a decade.
Whenever she had tried to discontinue her medication in the past, extreme anxiety had
caused her to resume it. At this point, she had good support and was highly motivated.
While remaining in the care of her treating psychiatrist, she consulted David Lake, M.D.,
with the hope that energy work would help her to be able to discontinue the drugs. He
reports:
I considered her request a tall order
because of the severity of the condition, my limited success using EFT with severe OCD,
and the potential complications for her. Nevertheless I thought that using and teaching
her to use meridian stimulation would be worthwhile. I did not know whether Diane would be
able to cease medication at alland I told her this. I notified her psychiatrist that
I was teaching her a relaxation and stress-management technique that could in some cases
have additional benefits as well.
Her symptoms included severe compulsive
"checking" of details about the house when going out, and re-checking in most
instances as she "forgot" whether she had really been certain of a detail. The
process might take an hour. She also suffered panic attacks and generalized anxiety. She
had recently developed a fear of flying and was due to fly shortly. I told her that we
would make an experiment using EFT and see how much benefit it returned to her.
Initially I taught her the variation of
meridian stimulation I call "continual tapping" (see
www.eftdownunder.com/articles_EFT.html#Continual) with good results. She noticed a great
lessening of the compulsive urge and was particularly pleased to know a self-help
technique. After a week, we began to explore her limiting beliefs about her OCD using
formal EFT and also using the provocative style that Steve Wells and I have found brings
great focus and leverage to a problem. Some of her greatest fears were that she would
never get over this and that she would have it forever, that there was nothing she could
do about it, and that it could get worse. Sometimes the fear during an anxiety attack was
"paralyzing" and "terrifying"; her ultimate fear was that "I
can't be reassured". There were several such intense panic incidents that needed a
lot of work to desensitize with tapping, using Gary's excellent "Tell the Story"
technique.5
Diane continued her practice at home
mainly using continual tapping for convenience. She used the tapping I taught her more
often and more effectively than anyone I can remember.
At the end of the third session she told
me that she had ceased her medication since she felt so well using EFT. I was alarmed,
since these medications should be ceased gradually, but because she seemed well we pressed
on. She told me that her fear had once returned but it was manageable and subsided with
the tapping after half an hour. Her fear of flying was also "95% gone" when she
next flew in a plane.
On another occasion about six weeks into
our treatment, she had a panic and anxiety attack lasting many hours, which did not
respond so well to EFT. This was a setback to her; nevertheless we continued the
experiment. There was another episode like this a few weeks later.
Diane remained in control of her symptoms
thereafter, using EFT. Her confidence increased and she functioned with a better balance,
more accepting and less self-critical. Her old checking habits and anxieties were still
there in a minor way, but did not interfere with her life. We had some six EFT sessions
over three months, and she became pregnant about six months later. She did have what I
would call ordinary anxieties about becoming pregnant and being a good mother. During the
later stage of her pregnancy, she did come to see me about an anxiety she "couldn't
shake," related to whether her worrying would harm the baby, and if the baby was in
fact alright. We dealt with the new fears in the same way as all her original fears and
presenting worriesa lot of continual tapping and traditional EFT on every specific
aspect we could think of. There was also the fear of the "unknown," of looking
after a dependent baby, and whether she would cope with the responsibilities.
Considering how universal these fears are
in mothers-to-be, I was struck by how "normal" their degree was for Diane. She
did not lose control and she did face up to the reality very well, learning more coping
skills and just understanding how other people cope too.
Her progress from the beginning was
surprising to me. I have not had this kind of rapid success before in such a severe case
of OCD, and with relatively few sessions.
This is a
clinical example, and it is appropriate that a therapist be involved with any case of
severe anxiety. By seeing how a more extreme situation was handled in a clinical setting,
however, you gain deeper instruction in how to apply the methods to everyday anxieties.
Treating Disabling Anxiety
Rikki,
a 25-year-old woman with a five-year history of agoraphobia (a fear of being in open areas
or public places) with severe panic symptoms, was referred for psychotherapy6 by a health care professional who had been
attempting to treat the anxiety using homeopathic remedies. Rikki refused to see a
psychiatrist because she was unwilling to consider taking traditional anti-anxiety
medications. Despite having a 22-month-old daughter, she had rarely left her house in the
15 months prior to entering therapy. She was overwhelmed with disabling anxiety and fears
of just about everything. She had not driven a car or left her block in all that time. She
had food and other supplies delivered.
Given
these circumstances, the therapist made home visits and supplemented them with phone
sessions. After Rikki learned the tapping procedure, the phone became a viable
alternative, where the therapist could coach her in applying the method as new situations
emerged. Rikki's anxiety about "unsafety in the world" was triggered and fueled
by a multitude of negative thoughts and belief systems that all started with "What
if . . ." followed by a "then . . ." statement that included a
worst case scenario. For example, "What if I start to drive to my grandmother's house
and then I get stuck in traffic at the corner of Main Street and Elm, and I have to go to
the bathroom, and I get nervous, and I'm stuck there, and then I can't get back home
again." Rikki was conscious and aware that her thoughts fueled her panic, but she had
no way to stop them.
The
therapy began by tracking Rikkis thoughts and her complex system of negative
beliefs. With each discovery of a new "nagging" thought, the Basic Recipe was
used to eradicate it. While she responded well, she would also frequently mention another
fear: that simply acknowledging her worries would escalate her anxiety. At these times,
the therapist would have her stop and tap on, "Even though continuing makes me feel a
little nervous . . ." Then she could continue. Rikki began to feel empowered by the
process of uncovering her negative thought patterns and having a way to disengage them.
After
the initial session, Rikki was able to walk out of her house without feeling anxious.
After the second session, she drove the three blocks into town, took her daughter to the
library, and began daily excursions. Her life was beginning to normalize. Even after she
uncovered a core issue and the anxiety returned, she was still able to go out into the
town.
The
core issue had to do with an LSD trip she had when she was 16 years old. She had been
traumatized by the "stuckness" of not being able to stop the hallucinations and
distortions she experienced for 12 interminable hours. She described her shame and guilt
about having taken the drug, as well as the traumatization. The work on this incident
required two sessions. The Basic Recipe was first used on her shame and guilt. Then on the
fact that she was allowing herself the memories and verbalizing them, since she believed
that talking or reliving the emotional experience would trigger an acid flashback. Next
was the feeling that it was unsafe to do this work and the fear that she would uncover
something that would propel her into even greater pain. She and her therapist became
partners in the process of uncovering and addressing her fears about doing energy work on
relieving the trauma of the acid trip itself, and then on her complex system of negative
beliefs. It was a profound experience for this young woman to free herself of her
agoraphobia and panic attacks by making peace with her "nagging anxiety thoughts and
all those what-ifs."
Applying the Basic Recipe to Anxiety
Again,
the point here is not to encourage you to treat yourself for a serious psychiatric
condition without the help of a qualified professional. Rather, by showing you how a
severe case of anxiety was successfully treated using the Basic Recipe, you will have a
stronger basis for applying the essential principles to help yourself with the normal
anxieties of everyday life.
And
most of us face anxiety-provoking circumstances every day. Turn on the news. Think on your
worries about your children, your health, your retirement. It is not necessary that we
enumerate; you know them all too well. But it is also not necessary, or useful, to dwell
on what can go wrong. Hanging out in anxiety and pessimism does not keep bad things from
happening or make you any more effective if they do. Keeping anxiety at bay is an
important skill in these troubling times. In fact, activating your optimism, rather than
causing you to be off-guard and vulnerable to more bad things, has the effect of making
you more resilient and effective in managing lifes challenges.7 Energy methods can help
you to turn off unnecessary anxiety and to transform negative, pessimistic
thinkingas you will see in the following chaptertoward an outlook that
highlights and promotes possibilities that are desirable and realistic.
Notice
that with Rikki, a traumatic memory was one of the core aspects of her anxiety, but
equally harmful were her intruding "what-if" thoughts and negative beliefs.
Remember how even as the energy methods were working, fears would emerge about the process
itself. She worried that "Simply acknowledging my worries will escalate my
anxiety" or "Just thinking about my LSD experience will cause a flashback."
As these negative thoughts would intrude, circling back on the treatment itself, the
therapist would patiently have them become the focus of the tapping treatments. You
can do that for yourself as well. As you focus on your anxiety, the aspects most likely to
emerge are memories from the past that contributed to current feelings of anxiety and
negative thoughts that feed them. Both will be responsive to the Basic Recipe. |
|
|
Depression |
|
|
An estimated forty million people in the U.S are
clinically depressed, and the numbers are increasing. Depression can cause persistent
sadness and lethargy, a sense of personal worthlessness, negative thoughts and
perceptions, a loss of interest in normal activities, changes in diet and sleep, and
frequent thoughts of death. Although medication treats the symptoms of depression in
millions of people, the precise causes and mechanisms of the disorder remain elusive.
Patients often must go through a period of trial-and-error before the best drug regimen is
identified, and even then the medication may not be as effective as hoped and will often
cause mild to severe side effects.
What
is well understood is that if you are depressed, your brain operates differently than it
does when you are not depressed. Restoring proper brain function is the goal of all
treatments for depressionwhether directly, as with medicationor indirectly, as
in the development of more life-affirming behaviors, attitudes, and habits of thought. By
sending electromagnetic impulses to the brain while focusing on various elements of the
depression, energy psychology can sometimes restore normal functioning quite
readily.
If
a person who is going through a difficult and seemingly endless series of challenges
becomes depressed, you can certainly understand it. Periods of depression serve a
function. Sometimes called "reactive depression," these episodes force you to
slow down, turn inward, and adjust to a loss or difficult circumstance. It is a healthy
response that can leave you stronger and more resilient. Or it can become
self-perpetuating, trapping you in a cycle of negative-thinking and self-doubt. When this
occurs, the Basic Recipe can be applied to the recent experiences that initiated the
depression ("Even though I miss Bill terribly . . .") as well as to various
other aspects of the depression, such as negative thought patterns ("Even though I
keep dwelling on the missed opportunities . . .") or unresolved early experiences
("Even though this reminds me of how devastated I felt when I was eleven and Grandma
died. . .").
A Woman Treats Herself for Longstanding
Depression
Maggie was
58 and all her life she had suffered with a "low grade" depression which, she
said, would never go away. "It has always been there in the background and at times
it was very intense." She had tried every healing modality she could find, short of
medication, from primal therapy to acupuncture to nutritional counseling. None had helped
sufficiently. She did report some benefit from having given up alcohol, coffee, and
tobacco, but she still hurt inside most of the time. Though she was strongly resistant to
taking psychiatric medication, she was considering it when she discovered EFT. Within two
days of learning and applying the method based on a home study course that teaches the
principles and techniques presented here, she reported that she "had healed stage
fright, and I started in on all my sad and angry feelings." Within a month, she was
no longer feeling depressed. Her friends began to comment on the changes they saw in her.
She then focused attention on her "denied creativity," and the poetry she at one
time enjoyed writing began "flowing again." She commented that her new
"healthy attitude" had started to seem so normal that she would "tend to
forget how bad things used to be. That's real progress!"
Major Depression
Not all
depression is a reaction to life events or negative thinking. Some peoples
neurochemistry predisposes them to be depressed. This kind of depression tends to run in
families and often has a genetic basis. The gene that influences whether you are more or
less vulnerable to becoming depressed after a traumatic event, for instance, has been
identified.8 In addition to genetics, early experiences,
extending all the way back to conditions in the mothers body during pregnancy, can
also predispose a person to depression.
The more that the
basis of the depression is in the genes or in early experiences, the more difficult it
usually is to treat, regardless of the clinical approach. In the treatment of
long-standing major depression, most psychotherapists, including energy-oriented
practitioners, supplement psychotherapy with psychiatric medication.9 Psychologist Patricia
Carrington explains that, otherwise, it can become "a test of endurance" when,
time and time again, the therapist may have helped the client become symptom-free by the
end of a session, but by the next appointment the gains seem to have evaporated.
Carrington
illustrates this by relating her work with Maria, a woman Carrington describes as being
highly intelligent and strongly motivated to overcome her irrational feelings of fear and
helplessness. However, they discovered early on in the treatment that although Maria would
often make excellent progress using the Basic Recipe, even dealing with core issues that
were central to her life, the therapy was still unable to "stem the tide" of the
depression. The despair and fear were just too much for her, and they were undermining her
progress. Bringing medication into the treatment made it possible to systematically work
with Marias irrational thoughts and sense of helplessness without the results being
dashed by the next wave of depression. The medication was introduced with the aim of
phasing it out as soon as Maria had built her inner strength. Combining Prozac with a
tapping approach led to "transformational work," in which Maria "has been
able to explore the deepest issues, some of them so early in origin as to be wordless, and
to one by one resolve them. And, with the support to our work that she has obtained from
the medication which didn't in itself solve her problems but did enable her to work
on them diligently in therapy she has rebuilt a self, has restructured
her relationships to people and the world . . . . She has voluntarily taken herself off of
all medication and is doing remarkably well in an exciting new phase of her
treatment."
Clinical research
supports this strategy. For patients with chronic depression, a combination of medication
and psychotherapy seems to prove more helpful than either treatment alone, both in terms
of reducing the symptoms10 and in improving overall functioning.11 Carrington concludes:
"Without the help of the drug we couldn't have done it, and similarly, if she had had
the drug alone without the therapy . . . at best the drug would have held her in a holding
pattern."
Applying the Basic Recipe to Depression
The
conventional psychotherapy that has been used most successfully in the treatment of
depression is Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT). CBT teaches people to interrupt
maladaptive thought patterns, such as ruminating on everything that might go wrong or
seeing the glass only as half empty or blaming themselves for things over which they have
no control. This approach has much in common with energy psychology, where you separate
complex reactions into their component thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. But energy
psychology adds a means for sending electromagnetic signals that directly shift the
neurological sequences involved with maladaptive thoughts and attitudes, often
deactivating them with surprising speed and precision. The successful treatment of
depression also often includes a number of commonsense lifestyle modifications that can be
supported with use of the Basic Recipe, such as increasing rest, decreasing stress,
introducing more physical exercise, and developing a better interpersonal support system.
A
powerful combination of energy interventions with Cognitive Behavior Therapy has been
developed by Hank Krol,12 a psychotherapist in
Pennsylvania. He gives his clients standardized checklists for assessing depression.13 They rate themselves on a
scale of 1 to 4 for each of 19 symptoms, according to the frequency the symptom is
experienced. Among the symptoms on the scale:
feelings
of guilt
irritable
mood
less
interest or pleasure in usual activities
withdrawing
from or avoiding people
finding
it harder than usual to do things
Another
checklist helps his patients identify the negative beliefs that accompany their
depression, such as
Identifying
these specifics separates the persons depression into its cognitive, affective, and
behavioral aspects. Each can then be targeted with energy interventions, using the Basic
Recipe much as you learned it in Chapter 2. Krol will generally select only one aspect for
a single session, two at the most. He will verify that it is important to the patient that
distress around this particular issue be reduced. If so, he will (unless the person
happens to be directly experiencing the issue at the moment) ask the person to recall a
recent situation where the symptom was experienced at a high intensity. The patient
applies the Basic Recipe, reducing as much as possible the rating on this aspect of the
depression during the session. Homework is also assigned to continue the process between
meetings.
In
the next session, another memory involving the same symptom or negative thought is
identified, rated, and treated if necessary. The patient keeps a focus on this same aspect
of the depression until it has been brought down to a 0 or near 0 or a different aspect
requires attention before it can be reduced further. Once it has been cleared, another
aspect is selected and worked with until it has been neutralized. Krol has found this
approach to be quite effective with many of his patients, but doing the suggested
self-treatments between sessions seems important to its success.
Different
types of depression need to be approached differently. Sometimes a depression simply
disappears with a few minutes of tapping. This can be very dramatic, but it is not usually
the case, particularly with a serious depression. More often, the depression appears to be
caused by numerous unresolved emotional issues such as guilt, shame, fear, grief, or
anger. These more complex or persistent depressions usually require work with a skilled
counselor who is able identify and focus on the core emotional issues. Even more
challenging are longstanding depressions where there is reason to suspect a strong
biological component. Here, even the best psychotherapy sometimes needs to be supplemented
by medication.
Again,
for major or ongoing depression, consult a health care professional, perhaps one who will
support you in using an energy approach as an adjunct to the therapy. In applying the
Basic Recipe to the more usual mood swings all of us must negotiate, the feature to adapt
from Krols approach is to be specific. If stating the generic problem such as
"Even though I have this depression . . ." does not give you distinct and
lasting improvement within a few rounds of the Basic Recipe, separate your depressed mood
into aspects such as negative thoughts, earlier times you felt depressed or engaged in
negative thinking, other instances where you tended to withdraw, et cetera, and treat them
one by one. As the core aspects of this depression lose their grip on you, not only
will the depression tend to lift, you will be building a resilience that makes you less
vulnerable to falling into future depression. |
|
|
Habits
and Addictions |
|
|
Beyond being able to apply the Basic Recipe to
each of the psychological aspects of addictionsuch as the cravings, the emotional
dependencies, and the personal history that led to the particular object of the
addictionenergy therapists are able to shift the dopamine and serotonin imbalances
that underlie addiction. The biochemical signature of a person who is predisposed to
addiction includes low levels of serotonin (a brain chemical that transmits nerve
impulses) combined with a tendency to too readily secrete dopamine (another
"neurotransmitter," whose actions are very different from those of serotonin).14 The correction of this
serotonin/dopamime imbalance using energy interventions exemplifies the way that energy
psychology can build on scientific understanding of the precise brain mechanisms involved
in difficult disorders for formulating effective treatment strategies, and we will discuss
in some detail the chemistry of addiction and the application of an energy approach in its
treatment.
The
Neurochemistry of Addiction. The neurochemistry of addiction has been closely studied and,
to a reasonable degree, mapped. While the following is a vast oversimplification, the
basic ingredients of addictive behavior are rooted in the same mechanisms nature created
to motivate us to do the three essential activities necessary for personal and species
survival: eating/drinking, avoiding harm, and reproducing. Our motivation toward these
activities is regulated by a small structure in the primitive brain called the
"nucleus accumbens" and by a dance within it between two brain
chemicalsdopamine and serotonin. Dopamine motivates you to do what is required to
obtain food, insure safety, and procreate. Once you are full, safe, or satisfied,
serotonin is secreted. Serotonin restrains the action of dopamine, turning off the
compelling motivation to address a primal need. According to Ron Ruden, M.D., Ph.D., in The
Craving Brain, dopamine sends the message "Gotta have itgo get it" and
serotonin sends the mission-accomplished message "Got it."15
When
you are hungry, for instance, the nucleus accumbens is sensitized to anything associated
with food or with ways to get food. When it recognizes something that can assuage your
hunger, it secretes dopamine to motivate you into action to obtain the food. Meanwhile, if
you are really hungry, your brain serotonin levels have become low. When serotonin levels
are down, the effects of dopamine are amplified, making its call to action an imperative.
You can think of little other than food. Once you have eaten, signals originating in your
digestive system increase your serotonin levels, your hunger subsides, and you feel a
sense of satiation and contentment.
Because
we evolved to be able to keep ourselves fed in as many circumstances as possible, it is
more than the mere presence of food that releases the dopamine that causes you to spring
into action. Images of food, plans for preparing a meal, thoughts of the family at the
dinner table, turning onto the street of a favorite restaurant, or a television
advertisement featuring veal parmesan may lead to the same sequence of internal events
that the scent of a rabbit initiated in your ancestors, and therein lies the vulnerability
to addiction. It is not only the presence of food, danger, or a desirable sexual
opportunity that sets the serotonin/dopamine dance into motion. Anything associated
with food, danger, or sexual opportunity can, when serotonin levels are low, cause high
enough dopamine levels to evoke the same focus and strength of motivation that nature
designed for critical survival situations.
Since
the mind can associate anything with anything, the possibilities for addiction are
endless. All that is necessary is that the triggering substance, situation, or symbol can
cause the release of dopamine within the addicts landscape of low serotonin. While
the object of choice will depend on a complex of the addicts neurochemistry,
environment, and history, dopamine levels may be sharply raised simply by thoughts of
alcohol, cigarettes, narcotics, cocaine, marijuana, food, or the behavior sequences
involved in gambling, sex, work, or shopping, as well as anything that becomes
symbolically associated with these substances or behaviors. Any of these may take a
leading role in the addictive drama of a person whose brain is predisposed with low
serotonin levels and a nucleus accumbens that secretes dopamine too readily.
An
addictionan excessive physical or psychological dependence on a substance or a
behavioris characterized by three successive states: 1) sobriety, 2) relapse, and 3)
compulsive, repetitive, coordinated behavior to obtain the substance or carry out the
activity that is the object of the addiction. For an addict, serotonin is low during the
craving state that precedes relapse, the nucleus accumbens is sensitized to finding the
object of the addiction or anything associated with it, high levels of dopamine are
secreted, and sobriety has moved into relapse. From there, the individual feels compelled
to pursue the addictive substance or behavior.
When
the object of the addiction is a behavior, such as gambling, sex, or shopping, the
behavior takes on a compulsive quality, performed without a sense of choice, sometimes
literally against ones own will. An addiction may also be deeply
entrenched in a persons self-concept or even be part of a cultural imperative. If
you grew up with the Marlboro Man as an image of masculinity, or if you primarily hang out
around people smoke, quitting will be harder than if you idolize the Dali Lama and are
trying to break the habit while spending the month at a yoga retreat.
Dopamine/Serotonin Imbalances
One of the
most intriguing observations to come out of the Argentina study is that stimulating
certain acupuncture points on the skin appears to increase serotonin levels in the brain.
While the potential implications of this finding are just beginning to be explored
clinically within energy psychology, a related area, neurofeedback training, has already
demonstrated measurable success in altering the brain chemistry of addicts.16 The images on the inside back cover of this
book show the progression of brain wave changes as a tapping protocol was administered to
a patient with generalized anxiety disorder. Neurofeedback produces the same kinds of
changes.
Rather than using
tapping to induce them, neurofeedback training involves connecting the person to an EEG
(electroencephalogram), an instrument that measures brainwaves. By receiving in-the-moment
information about the brains wave patterns the person is, somewhat remarkably but
quite reliably, able to willfully change those patterns in desired ways. With desire,
effort, and time, this training is capable of producing permanent changes in brain
chemistry that 1) reduce the amount of stress in the brains primal survival
mechanismspresumably allowing the levels of serotonin to naturally increase, and 2)
appear to make the nucleus accumbens less reactive to the desired objectless poised
to secrete the dopamine that causes one to obsessively pursue the desired object. Clinical
reports now suggest that the tapping protocol with addictions may have similar effects. In
fact, Dr. Ruden, a pioneer in treating addiction by altering serotonin/dopamine imbalances
without the use of medication, is finding that variations of the EFT Basic Recipe seem
more effective than neurofeedback training for dealing with cravings and perhaps as
effective in establishing better serotonin/dopamine balances by altering the persons
stress response patterns.17
The Basic Recipe and Addictions
Can the
Basic Recipe, simply applied to an addiction or to a deeply ingrained pattern such as
"this gambling habit," overcome the addiction? No harm trying, but usually not.
Less complex habits and cravings, however, may be more responsive. A craving is an intense
desire for a specific substance or activity. Sometimes, all that is necessary is to treat
the craving. Cases have been reported where cravings for coffee, soft drinks, or chocolate
have been completely and permanently eliminated (and occasionally the substance actually
becomes repulsive) after a single session using the tapping protocol. For instance, the
Setup Affirmation "Even though I have this craving for chocolate, I deeply love and
accept myself" would be followed by tapping on the Reminder Phrase "longing for
chocolate." You can initially measure the distress around the issue by saying, for
instance, "Im quitting chocolate" and then giving the 0 to 10 rating on
the discomfort or anxiety this causes you. Continue subsequent rounds until the rating is
down to 0.
While it is
relatively rare for this procedure to permanently undo a well-entrenched habit in a single
sitting, it is at least a powerful tool for overcoming immediate "in the moment"
cravings so that a more comprehensive approach is able to gain ground. The "one day
at a time" attitude toward addictions advanced by Alcoholics Anonymous and other
addiction programs emphasizes the importance of staying alert for an addictions
sudden pull, and the Basic Recipe is an effective tool to have in your back pocket 24/7.
When energy
interventions are systematically applied to the different aspects of an addiction or
self-destructive habit, however, their power is greatly expanded.18 They can loosen the
addictions grip and frequently free the person from it completely. Among the
dynamics that can be targeted with energy interventions:
elevated
dopamine/reduced serotonin imbalances in the brain, as discussed above
mentally
generated stressors (e.g., guilt, hate, anger, envy) that lower serotonin levels
the anxiety or
emptiness that arises when the substance or activity is not supplied
the ways the
addiction is tied into the persons self-concept
the ways the
addiction is tied into the persons life-style
the physical
suffering of withdrawal
the cultivation
of other sources of primal pleasure
The tapping
protocol can be adapted to address each element of the addictive syndrome. Again, this
often requires skilled guidance and may need to be combined with other methods, such as
AA-type support groups and relaxation or meditation training, but the overview provided
here can at least help you with milder habits, and they demonstrate the underlying
principles for approaching any addictive behavior.
Treating a Food Addiction
Carol Look is a
psychotherapist who has been particularly successful in using an energy approach to help
people overcome addictions such as smoking and overeating.19 She describes Ann, a
woman who was referred for weight loss by the physician who was treating her for back pain
(caused by severe sciatica) and knee pain (following knee replacement surgery a year
earlier). When Ann first called, she reported feeling scared. While she was embarrassed
about being overweight and knew her excess weight was exacerbating her physical pains and
undermining her overall health, she hadnt felt ready to tackle this issue. In the
first session, Ann identified three emotional reasons for her overeating: 1) to soothe a
sense of emptiness she could trace to her upbringing with a cold mother and absent father,
2) to comfort her when the physical pain was overbearing, and 3) to fill a void from
feeling starved of emotional and physical affection from her husband. Over four months of
treatment, Dr. Look helped Ann address each of these areas with EFT. During this period
Ann lost 25 pounds without pressuring herself to change her eating patterns. With the EFT
treatment, unlike her experiences with dieting, Ann reported that she was thrilled because
she didnt feel deprived by the changes in her eating habits. She was still able to
eat her favorite foods, but she had a new awareness about what her body needs. She no
longer had to "eat to fill the [emotional] starvation" she had always felt. Ann
described how food was no longer central in her life. "I eat moderately and am more
conscious of when Im full and what I need. . . . I enjoy not cramming food down my
throat anymore."
Addressing and
neutralizing the underlying emotional states that drove Ann to binge and overeat in the
first place were central to her treatment. Each of the three emotional reasons Ann
identified for her overeating was addressed in depth. Her mother, for instance, continued
to be an active player in Anns emotional turmoil. Ann had been overweight most of
her life, and she described how she sometimes used food to "stick it to" her
mother. By eating when she was irritated with her mother, she could show that she was
"in charge." She understood that this was self-defeating, but she found herself
unable to stop using food in this way when she was feeling angry or resentful. In her
words, "I eat to squash the turmoil." In their adult relationship, Ann felt as
if her mother was the child. She never felt heard or understood. In one confrontation, her
mother told her she didnt think Ann was likable. Meanwhile, Ann was still as hungry
for her mothers love and acceptance as she was while a girl. As a result, she was
chronically angry at her mother, and their ongoing relationship difficulties were
intertwined with Anns overeating. Here are some of the Setup Affirmations used in
Anns treatment to address her relationship with her mother:
"Even
though my mother doesnt even like me, I completely like and accept myself."
"Even
though my mother doesnt think Im good enough, I choose to believe Im
lovable and good enough."
"Even
though I use food to comfort my loneliness, I deeply and completely accept myself."
"Even
though my mother has never understood me, I accept her for who she is."
"Even
though my mother is too selfish to hear me, I accept my own feelings anyway."
Other sequences
focused on her physical pain and her relationship with her husband. In each, the core
issue and its aspects were reduced to 0. Sample Setup Affirmations around the physical
pain included:
"Even though I
feel enraged by my pain, I deeply and completely accept myself."
"Even though
my pain reminds me of my mother, and I feel resentful, I deeply and completely accept
myself, including the pain."
Affirmations that
addressed her marriage included:
"Even though
Im not appreciated for what I do, I love and appreciate myself anyway."
"Even though I
feel angry when he doesnt listen to me, I choose to listen to myself.
"Even though I
feel rejected and it feels painful, I deeply and completely accept myself."
Along with having
lost the weight, by the end of the four months of treatment, Ann reported that she was no
longer triggered by her mother or her husband, and she felt much more at peace with her
childhood and its emotional deprivations. While recognizing that neither her mother nor
her husband had changed in any way during the four months, she felt confident that she
could identify and process all of her feelings in relationship to both of them. She
harbored no desire to abuse food as a way to stuff her feelings or avoid the realities of
these relationships. In the late afternoons, when Ann used to binge on cookies and sweets,
she was now taking the time to be by herself, read, think about her feelings, and tap.
Applying the Basic Recipe to Habits and
Addictions
The
emotional baggage carried with any addiction or difficult habit can be systematically
addressed, as you saw with Ann. Early in the treatment, Dr. Look asks her clients to
identify the downside of overcoming their addictions. The answers often point to
psychological reversals and other emotional aspects of the pattern. For instance, a
"downside" Ann identified in relationship to stopping her afternoon food binges
was that she would feel dissatisfied and angry all the time and wouldnt know what to
do with those feelings. She also said she feared that she would have to come to terms with
all the turmoil in her life, and she acknowledged that the extra weight was being used as
protection against years of emotional pain and feelings of rejection and abandonment.
Along
with healing the emotional components that underlie an addiction, energy interventions can
provide a way of dealing with cravings as they occur in the moment. While we know of no
laboratory studies that track this specifically, we suspect that tapping on a specific
craving impacts the dopamine/serotonin imbalances discussed earlier. In working with
smokers, Look will ask her clients to take out a cigarette, smell it, and rate their
current desire, craving, or urge on the 0 to 10 scale. Then the Basic Recipe is used to
reduce the craving as it exists right then in the office: "Even though I have this
craving to smoke now . . ." She will then ask her clients to identify three or four
times of the day they most like to smoke and will apply the Basic Recipe to bring down
each of them. If smoking with their morning coffee is one of their favorite times, Look
would have them imagine having their morning coffee and giving a rating to how much they
want a cigarette. Then the Basic Recipe is applied to each of these situations where the
trigger for the addiction is strong, using a Setup such as "Even though I want to
smoke when I drink my morning coffee . . . " or "Even though I have this urge to
smoke after dinner . . ."
Once
bringing down these urges, Look reverses the situation. Clients are asked to imagine
themselves having their morning coffee without a cigarette, and they rate the level of
anxiety or upset they feel. This can then be treated using the Basic Recipe, but it is a
time to stay particularly alert for additional emotions that keep an addiction in place.
Once these aspects of the addiction can be identified, they can be treated one by one.
Among the feelings that | |